Defining Evolution, the Theory of Evolution, and Evolutionism

Within the Creation and Evolution debate, many discussions turn chaotic because individuals do not understand the differences between the generic use of evolution, the scientific Theory of Evolution, and the philosophical beliefs of Evolutionism. Quite often (usually by accident but sometimes intentionally), these concepts are mixed together in various ways which produces logical fallacies, what is known as a ‘strawman argument’, or lengthy attempts to prove a fruitless point. By properly defining each of these terms, hopefully discussions can move forward and with more peace.

Evolution

The word ‘evolution’ comes from the Latin word ‘evolutio’ which technically refers to the ‘unrolling of a scroll’. It is a term with a broad range of uses. Many things are said to evolve including the development of an idea, a product, a chemical reaction, or even mountains as they rise and erode. The first recorded use of evolution in regards to biology came with the description of an embryo’s development.

Theory of Evolution

When people refer to evolution, most commonly they are thinking of the scientific study of biological evolution which is formally contained in the Theory of Evolution. The Theory of Evolution has been defined and described in many ways. One of the basic definitions is a change in allele frequencies in a gene pool through the generations which can more simply be described as genetic variations that exist within a population over time. It can be summed up nicely in the phrase ‘descent with genetic modification’.

Darwin and Natural Selection

Charles Darwin wrote a book with the title ‘On the Origin of Species by Natural Selection’. This is often talked about as being the Theory of Evolution … it is not. Instead, the book is primarily about Natural Selection which is just one process that produces evolutionary change. It is a method for life to evolve from a single common ancestor to the many species found through history and today.

Modern Evolutionary Synthesis

The modern Theory of Evolution contains many more concepts than just natural selection. The most important addition is combining the process of natural selection to the mechanism of genetic inheritance. This mechanism helps to describe how evolution takes place. The modern concept also focuses on populations, rather than individuals, and includes the effects of genetic drift.

The Theory of Evolution does not State Purpose or Direction

Over time, evolution has had different uses within science. Before Darwin’s time, evolution was used in conjunction with species transmutation which stated that species did have a predetermined direction to move in. This idea has since been discarded. Evolution is now depicted as a tree moving in many directions at once. It no longer implies a purpose or a direction and the most recent species are not necessarily the best. The branches on this tree will include both failures and successes. The next step in evolution cannot be predicted.

Microevolution and Macroevolution

When the Theory of Evolution speaks of microevolution, it is referring to genetic changes that occur within a species or population over time. It includes such ideas as bacteria building up immunity to vaccines. When it refers to Macroevolution, it refers to the much larger accumulation of changes that produce speciation from a common ancestor and the separation of the higher taxa. It includes the development of gills for breathing underwater or spores for plant reproduction.

[It should be noted that within a creation viewpoint, the term microevolution is often defined as changes within a Created Kind and macroevolution refers to [supposed] changes above or outside of a Kind. This effectively places the micro- / macro- change at the Family level of classification rather than at the species level and thus causes tremendous confusion].

Evolutionism

When people think of evolution as moving from a lower life form to a higher life form or the development from a primitive ancestor to a specialized state, they are now in the realms of Evolutionism. This generally involves a long gradual process with the formation of life starting about 3.5 billion years ago. More formally, Evolutionism is a belief that organisms increase in complexity over time and improve through progressive inherited change.

Darwinism

Darwinism is possibly the most abused term in this short list because Darwinism and Darwinist are incorrectly used in a derogatory way to refer to athiestic evolution. In reality, the term actually has a long history of use. In 1860, Thomas Huxley introduced the term ‘Darwinism’ in regards to Darwin’s book. A few years later, Herbert Spencer summed up Darwinism with the phrase ‘survival of the fittest’ – how natural selection is most commonly known today. If a proper definition can be given to Darwinism, it would probably be similar to ‘biological evolution by natural selection’. (which is not to be confused with the modern Theory of Evolution).

Additional Concepts

Rightly or wrongly, Evolutionism is often associated with many other concepts. It carries with it some of the philosophical presuppositions of Naturalism and Materialism in which only the physical aspects of the universe exist or are considered as relevent. It typically includes the Big Bang Theory of Origins for the appearance of the Universe. It implies a uniformitarian view of Earth’s history for the formation of the planet we now see. It is also connected with Abiogenesis – the idea that life had to come from non-living matter at some point to start the evolutionary process. These concepts blur the lines between science and philosophy, but in real life worldviews must be dealt with.

When dealing with topics that can be viewed in theology, science, and philosophy one must be careful not to confuse the issues. It is not unusual to see the Theory of Evolution (a scientific inquiry) and Creationism (a belief) compared and discussed with almost chaotic results. Instead, Creationism should be compared with Evolutionism and the scientific Theory of Created Kinds should be compared to the Theory of Evolution. This helps maintain a balanced and fair examination of the topics being discussed. This is easier said than done when the same word(s) can have so many different uses and meanings.

Todd Elder

Todd Elder

Todd Elder has a deep desire to understand and experience Creation. As a Baraminologist, his current research includes developing the Katagenos Species Concept, the Natanzera Classification System, and the Floral Formula Method of determining Plant Kinds. As an author and speaker, his books and seminar materials are designed to encourage a growing relationship with the Creator.
Todd Elder

Latest posts by Todd Elder (see all)

Enjoyed this article ? --> Share it .

If you appreciate this information, please consider donating
to help defray the costs of this website and ongoing research.